Judgments are intrinsic to this illusory dream that we live in, because this dream is one of differences, as opposed to the Oneness that is God and of which we are a part. So any judgment or preference is an illusion, regardless of how minor you see it or how you place it in your hierarchy of preferences. All of these judgments come from your ego mind, because this ego mind was created out of judgment. The ego exists solely because we have judged ourselves. Its thoughts can only be ones of judgment. Thus the ego, because it was created out of judgment, cannot lead you out of judgment. You must go to the Source, that Self which shares the Mind of God and which has judged itself as not worthy, thus creating an ego mind for this dream.
What would it be like if you didn't judge anything? Complete freedom, complete peace. We believe that judgment is a sword we carry to protect ourselves, but this is the farthest from the Truth. We carry a sword, because we fear attack from other egos. But our safety lies in defenselessness, not defensiveness. This was Jesus' true message. The Love that we are protects us and keeps us safe, because we have never left God and His Love.